Andrea Harner
rssicon15.jpg
andreaharnerblog AT gmail
This site is a member of the Blogads NYC Blog network!
Favorites
Dates

May 2, 2006

United 93

United93.jpg

I thought I'd be the last person to see United 93 given that when I saw the preview I recoiled in horror and thought it was much too soon and would invariably be a horrifically tasteless representation of a tragedy.

But I heard that critics were giving it rave reviews across the board so my interest was piqued. Jonah and I went to see it on opening night which we hardly ever do because it's a madhouse but I knew that there would be perhaps as many people who would boycott it as go to see it so sure enough we got good seats and enjoyed (as much as you can enjoy this sort of movie) this surpisingly good movie.

The main highlights were that they didn't emotionally manipulate you in that way that Hollywood is excellent at and it was apolitical and didn't hit you over the head with a political message. It mostly, in my opinion, demonstrated how inefficient bureacracies can be at such great expense.

As NYTimes' Manohla Dargis reviewed, "a persuasively narrated, scrupulously tasteful re-creation" of the downing of the fourth and final plane hijacked by Islamist terrorists on Sept. 11..."



Comments

I couldn't agree more. Even though our political views skew opposing, it's great to see that a movie when done tastefully can provide points that can unify a people rather than divide it. (As we as a nation all to often do)

It was painful to watch, but worth it.

Posted by: will at May 2, 2006 2:12 PM

Um, your interest was piqued. Though you were feeling peeked when the story peaked.

Posted by: yellowdesk at May 2, 2006 8:41 PM

YellowDesk,

Thank you, I stand corrected!

:-)
A

Posted by: Andrea at May 3, 2006 9:10 AM

here's a different take: it was inappropraite to make this movie because we are still in the middle of the war on terrorism. the leader of the group responsible still has not even been apprehended. http://www.pressthenews.com/aq_ldr.htm it needs to be "historical" for profit to be made off of it, and while it is, and always will be, "monumental" it is not yet historical. unfortunately, it is still fresh. this has nothing to do with the "psychological" fact of seeing the film, which everyone keeps discussin as if that is the issue.

anyway, just a take

Posted by: pressthenews at May 5, 2006 6:16 PM
BuzzFeed
Screen Junkies finally shows us an honest Transformers trailer. "What the hell is happening?"
10 Superbly Sensual Faces. Numbering is in the eye of the beholder.
In a perfect world, every meal would be as epic as breakfast. Whether it's the pancakes, eggs or french toast that helps get your morning off to the perfect start, tell us by using the hashtag #BreakfastLove.
Add BuzzFeed to Your Site
Video projects



This Website was designed by Cat Savard